logoalt Hacker News

udev409601/21/20253 repliesview on HN

Clever finding but the title does no justice to the actual attack. Even a bare minimum threat model requires a user to use VPN or Tor which completely eliminates your "0day". Signal rightfully declined your report because it's only job is to provide secure communication


Replies

lxgr01/21/2025

Signal is definitely also aiming to provide metadata privacy, which they understand to be part of secure communication.

Otherwise, they wouldn't pad attachment and message sizes, offer a "sealed sender" feature, allow relaying all calls to avoid callers/callees from learning users' IP addresses etc.

iforgot2201/22/2025

Typical mobile user with a VPN is still vulnerable as far as I can tell, because they may be disconnected while displaying a push notification, but feel free to prove me wrong: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42786466

show 1 reply
mmooss01/21/2025

Signal is intended not for HN readers, but for ordinary people who don't understand VPNs and Tor.