logoalt Hacker News

moduspol01/21/20251 replyview on HN

Can't we just use literal prisoners?

That's what I always thought about the kind of research RFK Jr is always talking about. Normally it's not ethical to do food / medicine trials with prisoners, but these would be trials like giving regular food to one set of prisoners and food without dyes or chemicals to the other. The "test group" would just be getting healthier food.

Seems like just radically measuring portion sizes might fit into the same kind of thing. And you could probably measure activity level more easily, too.


Replies

bluGill01/21/2025

You can use prisoners and it has been done. However there are enough differences between prison and normal life that it is questionable if your results apply outside of prison.