logoalt Hacker News

vel0city01/21/20251 replyview on HN

> Signal can and should append some noise to the images when encrypted (or better yet, pad them to a set file size as suggested by paulryanrogers in a sibling comment) to mitigate the risks of this attack for those who do have threat models that require it

Adding padding to the image wouldn't do anything to stop this "attack". This is just watching which CF datacenters cache the attachment after it gets sent.


Replies

lolinder01/21/2025

Right, my bad on the ambiguity—I was replying to the OP's concern about image sizes, not the attack in TFA:

> It really doesn't matter that they can't see an image or video, knowing its size upfront or later (for example in response to a law enforcement request) is enough

show 1 reply