logoalt Hacker News

mmooss01/21/20251 replyview on HN

This is all the classic dismissals of security issues, including blaming the user.

> opsec failure for the Signal user

Signal's mission is to provide security for users who don't know the word 'opsec'.


Replies

alp1n3_eth01/21/2025

Blaming the user is sometimes what it boils down to. Security includes a balancing act that involves usability, and Signal is firstly targeting the masses, but includes settings that can be configured for high-risk scenarios.

This "vulnerability" requires the user to have none of the normal things a person with a more extreme threat model would have already configured. EZPZ guides online on locking down Signal.

It's just like an iPhone. They don't ship with Lockdown Mode enabled by default, as it hurts the average consumer's usability. Signal at minimum will ensure no one is snooping on your messages, and it's up to the user whether they want to take that further.

If your definition of not providing security is allowing someone to know they exist on a continent, then that user's ISP has performed terribly as well since they aren't bouncing their signal around the world by default.

show 1 reply