logoalt Hacker News

svnt01/21/20251 replyview on HN

The important part about the statements in the drift paper are the qualifiers:

> Cells whose activity was previously correlated with environmental and behavioral variables are most frequently no longer active in response to the same variables weeks later. At the same time, a mostly new pool of neurons develops activity patterns correlated with these variables.

“Most frequently” and “mostly new” —- this means that some neurons still fire across the weeks-long periods for the same activities, leaving plenty of potential space for concept cells.

This doesn’t necessarily mean concept cells exist, but it does allow for the possibility of their existence.

I also didn’t check which regions of the brain were evaluated in each concept, as it is likely they have some different characteristics at the neuron level.


Replies

westurner01/21/2025

So there's more stability in the electrovolt wave function of the brain than in the cellular activation pathways?

show 1 reply