logoalt Hacker News

ForHackernews01/22/20254 repliesview on HN

Being pessimistic, how come no human supergeniuses ever took over the world? Why didn't Leibniz make everyone else into his slaves?

I don't even understand what the proposed mechanism for "rouge AI enslaves humanity" is. It's scifi (and not hard scifi) as far as I can see.


Replies

HeatrayEnjoyer01/22/2025

> Being pessimistic, how come no human supergeniuses ever took over the world? Why didn't Leibniz make everyone else into his slaves?

We already did. Look at the state of animals today vs <1 mya. Bovines grown in unprecedented mass numbers to live short lives before slaughter. Wolves bred into an all new animal, friendly and helpful to the dominate species. Previously apex predators with claws, teeth, speed and strength, rendered extinct.

show 1 reply
Philpax01/22/2025

Once you have one AGI, you can scale it to many AGI as long as you have the necessary compute. An AGI never needs to take breaks, can work non-stop on a problem, has access to all of the world's information simultaneously, and can interact with any system it's connected to.

To put it simply, it could outcompete humanity on every metric that matters, especially given recent advancements in robotics.

show 1 reply
arisAlexis01/22/2025

This is profoundly and disturbingly bad argument.

1)Leibniz wasn't superhuman 2) Leibniz couldn't work 24/7 3) he could not self increase the speed of his own hardware (body) 4) he could not spawn 1 trillion copies of him to work 24/7

Like how much time did you think before writing this

show 1 reply
z3phyr01/22/2025

I consider many successful military leaders and politicians to be geniuses as well. In my books, Caesar is as genius as Newton!

Having said that, we do not to understand the world to exploit it for ourselves. And what better way to understand and exploit the universe than science? Its an endearment.