logoalt Hacker News

TeMPOraL01/22/20251 replyview on HN

> The moment you use a fraction, the assumption is that you would need to count all I guess, so it’s treated as individual objects.

I always explained it to myself that, when you use a fraction, you're focusing on that one incomplete object, also calling more attention to the individuality of objects in the set. So in case of say, "100.5 książki", I like to imagine shoving ~95 books into the box very quickly, then slowing down for the last 6 books, counting them off one by one, to know exactly when to stop and saw the 106th book in half.

IDK what the official justification is.


Replies

alterom01/22/2025

Interesting.

It's the opposite in Russian — it'd be "100½ książek" there (сто c половиной книжек), even though it's "½ książki" (половина книжки).

"½ książek" (половина книжек) is also valid, and it means "half of (all the) books".

But in "100½", it's the whole number that determines the ending (i.e. case) of the word.

show 1 reply