logoalt Hacker News

KaiserPro01/22/20251 replyview on HN

Thats not how it works or what happened.

You can only be given a sentence for the crime you have been convicted of, otherwise you could easily appeal.

> Is this reasonable? Should we be satisfied with how this works and not want to change anything about it?

It doesn't work like that, and I wouldn't be satisfied by a court system that does work like that. It'd fucking disastrous. If anyone convinces you that it does work like that, they are either a scammer, or want to make the law system _very_ scary.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Habeas_corpus_in_the_United_St... which have been there for _many_ years. Its a common law principle that at least twice as old as the USA.


Replies

AnthonyMouse01/22/2025

> You can only be given a sentence for the crime you have been convicted of, otherwise you could easily appeal.

If you're convicted of a crime, let's say selling drugs, that carries a penalty of up to life in prison even though most people get 5-10 years, and then you're sentenced to life in prison after the person doing the sentencing is prejudiced by these murder allegations you've never been convicted of, what's your basis for appeal?

show 1 reply