logoalt Hacker News

cptskippylast Wednesday at 6:26 PM2 repliesview on HN

> Qi2 is based on Magsafe.

That's an insult to all of the engineering that went into Qi.

The Magsafe specification was an attempt to create the new Lightning connector ecosystem that backfired spectacularly and blew up in Apple's face. It's nothing more than magnets and DRM layered on top of a regular Qi charger.

Naturally Apple used the DRM to limit the charging speeds of their phones when paired with regular Qi chargers. There's a practical reason for this which is how Apple tried to justify their outrageous licensing fee to implement Magsafe.

Unfortunately for Apple, manufacturers mostly said no to Magsafe licensing and Apple's user based complained to Apple that their phones wouldn't charge at the rated speeds of the Qi chargers they bought.

This put Apple in an awkward position where they could tell their users to only buy MagSafe devices, compromise on safety to appease users, or give up on Magsafe being proprietary. Thankfully they chose the later.

Qi2 isn't Magsafe, Qi2 incorporated Magsafe because it improves the standard.

Don't let Apple marketing fool you into thinking Apple is doing this altruistically.


Replies

GeekyBearlast Wednesday at 6:52 PM

From the article linked above:

> With the blessing of competitors, Apple is about to change the Qi wireless standard itself. It’s contributing to a new version of Qi that works much like MagSafe — magnets, authentication, and all.

show 1 reply
pertymcpertlast Thursday at 12:16 AM

So what I'm seeing is that Qi2 is based on MagSafe then.

show 1 reply