logoalt Hacker News

petefordelast Wednesday at 8:26 PM2 repliesview on HN

Putting aside every instinct I have to join the choir voicing every issue I have with blaming the victim and cozying up to the agitator, or to challenge your charitable view of Trump's motivations...

I'm genuinely interested to hear your take on the likely and potential repercussions of rewarding Russia/Putin for their aggression. What makes you confident that they won't reasonably perceive this outcome as tacit permission to start coming for other territory?

Putin loves working off maps from the 1800s. Finland, for example, is a likely future target.

Not to be hyperbolic, but there's a good reason you aren't supposed to negotiate with terrorists.


Replies

shikon7last Wednesday at 8:58 PM

I have no confidence at all. In fact, preventing further Russian aggression might not be Trump's goal to begin with. After all, Trump did say he would encourage Russia to invade a country that didn't pay its due.

Ray20last Wednesday at 10:32 PM

>What makes you confident that they won't reasonably perceive this outcome as tacit permission to start coming for other territory?

Putin has approximately zero interest in territories and annexations. The entire war with Ukraine is exclusively a reaction to the Maidan in 2014, an attempt to prevent something similar in Russia.

Talks about "rewarding Russia" - is literally Putin's propaganda to hide his complete failure. There is no reward, the whole current situation in which Putin put himself, when his authority and influence is lower then ever - was planned as a short two week campaign with no downsides.

show 1 reply