logoalt Hacker News

threeseed02/19/20252 repliesview on HN

> EOs are subject to judicial review and are only valid if there's a congressional or constitutional basis

This is just nonsense.

Trump, for example, recently signed an EO to end the use of paper straws.

Where is your justification that there is a valid congressional or constitutional basis for this ? Of course there isn’t. Executive Orders allow the President to interpret existing laws as they see fit. Even in ways they were never intended to be interpreted.


Replies

gortok02/20/2025

Executive Orders were meant to give instructions to the executive branch on how to “faithfully execute the law”. They turned into — through several presidents, a way to bind the executive branch to a particular way of interpreting the law —- or in some cases —- making law out of whole cloth.

Trump is continuing this trend, and while we should all be concerned as to where he takes it, congress and the judiciary share the blame for not reigning in prior presidents.

show 1 reply