logoalt Hacker News

lacy_tinpotlast Thursday at 11:10 AM3 repliesview on HN

You call the first and one of the most successful democracies in the world a monarchy/dictatorship? The American Executive branch is given broad powers since the very beginning and considering the success there might be something to it.

In contrast the Europeans have descended into petty mass wars and dictatorial regimes multiple times, and each time America has come to save Europe through that very Executive branch.

A bit thankless don't you think?


Replies

lazyasciiartlast Thursday at 8:08 PM

America has never saved anyone unless they thought it was from a threat to America.

And no, the executive branch had much less power “in the beginning”. As many people have learned, what America’s constitution says has never really matched what America does. The increasing mindless worship of a dead text, called “originalism”, is part of what will destroy it.

lupusreallast Thursday at 11:17 AM

Europe has more or less managed to avoid descending into a mass war for almost a century now, if we assume the one brewing now is just a mirage, so basically they've got it all figured out and their smugness is totally justified.

This is what democracy looks like, Americans should learn from Germany's example:

> According to the court document, the public prosecutor stated “public interest” in pressing criminal charges as the retweet was “punishable as an insult against people of political life”. It potentially constituted “incitement of the people”.

> Publicly insulting a politician has been a criminal offence in Germany since 2021 when a set of laws “against hate and hate speech” were passed under then-chancellor Angela Merkel.

https://brusselssignal.eu/2024/11/german-police-raid-mans-ho...

show 4 replies
IsTomlast Thursday at 11:51 AM

> You call the first and one of the most successful democracies in the world

That's the level of delusion in your own greatness that led to Trump. USA was the first (representative!) democracy with written constitution at best. And that's if you overlook the fact that only some people were entitled to vote at all.