logoalt Hacker News

madeofpalk02/20/20254 repliesview on HN

Any sufficiently advanced incompetence is indistinguishable from malice


Replies

CyrsBel02/20/2025

This is correct. Depending on the stakes, the right answer would be to err on the side of caution. Certainly repeated incompetence in a private setting would be grounds for suspension or termination.

godelski02/20/2025

At what point does incompetence /become/ malice?

There is certainly a level of incompetence that requires active ignorance to one's naivety. I'd certainly consider a stubborn person who arrogantly ignores concerns of experts malicious. The active nature certainly matters.

show 1 reply
specialist02/20/2025

Yes and: fraud and errors are often indistinguishable.

cempaka02/20/2025

People with malice like Elon Musk have noticed the widespread use of this aphorism and repeatedly leverage it to their advantage.