logoalt Hacker News

fiddlerwoarooflast Thursday at 7:21 PM2 repliesview on HN

I don’t understand the hatred for select multiple on desktop. It’s a list box that uses standard UI conventions that have been present for three or four decades now.


Replies

TeMPOraLlast Thursday at 7:37 PM

They're probably referring to it not being usable without keyboard, unlike regular select, or checkboxes, or anything else sans a text field. Specifically, to select elements one by one, you need to hold down Ctrl (on Windows; modifiers for other OSes are different).

For better or worse, this element is not obvious for those who didn't grow up using desktop computers 10+ years ago.

streptomycinlast Thursday at 11:16 PM

I use it in one place in my app, and even with me putting text right above it saying something like "ctrl+click to select multiple entries", I still periodically get emails from confused users. No idea what the actual % is, but it's gotta be some non-trivial fraction of people who just have no idea how to use that thing.

show 1 reply