logoalt Hacker News

abraae02/20/20251 replyview on HN

Sounds like an argument over semantics and the meaning of the word "breakthrough".

Running the 4 minute mile, climbing everest - those are achievements rather than breakthroughs.

I'd also class the atomic bomb as an achievement - it was the expected/desired result of a massive investment program - though no doubt there were many breakthroughs required in order to achieve that result.


Replies

globnomulous02/21/2025

Yup, it's semantics, because the comment I answered stresses "by definition." My point is partly that that isn't the definition.

Even if we decide that breakthroughs require some kind of discontinuity, break, or, as the comment said, "paradigm shift," such discontinuity isn't necessarily "against the grain," as this would imply some kind of resistance to or rejection of "the grain."

show 1 reply