logoalt Hacker News

fragmede04/01/20254 repliesview on HN

> - It will have new cells rather than used ones.

This is not a feature. Our Earth is a limited resource, and being able to reuse batteries instead of discarding them to the trash is a desirable property.


Replies

beacon29404/01/2025

There's even more to the riddle. Lithium recycling, cost of the power loss in old cells. Power transmit cost. Cost of power generation on site.

nine_k04/01/2025

Pick used EV or industrial batteries. This must be much more efficient due to a larger cell size than in laptops.

OTOH used laptop batteries can likely be obtained for effectively zero monetary cost, while used EV or solar backup batteries still cost quite noticeable money per kWh. With laptop batteries, you pay with your time; if you for some reason have an excess supply thereof, or you just enjoy this kind of work as a pastime.

pbasista04/02/2025

> Our Earth is a limited resource

Of course. No one disputes that. I was just trying to point out that you can get better cells for less money.

> being able to reuse batteries instead of discarding them to the trash is a desirable property

I fully agree. No one is trying to suggest that we should discard used batteries into trash.

UltraSane04/01/2025

We have LOTS of lithium

show 1 reply