logoalt Hacker News

anyfoo04/02/20252 repliesview on HN

No offense, but... when I was reading your story, I was somehow at least assuming that the marking on the part was somewhat unreadable or something...

After getting befuddling answers, would it not have been natural to check the base assumptions, starting with do I have the correct part? That is true as much in the "real engineering" world, as in school.

You say "It could _never_ be the equipment's fault" as if it was, but it wasn't. The test equipment gave you correct answers, your device under test was wrong.


Replies

Bjartr04/02/2025

I'd say it's not natural to check for the correct part that has been given to you by an authority that claims to have done so, but a learned problem solving technique.

opello04/02/2025

Or even more likely in a lab setting: have another student test your part in their setup for A/B validation testing.

show 1 reply