logoalt Hacker News

delichonlast Wednesday at 7:32 PM3 repliesview on HN

The "What [the political spectrum] Actually Is" graph shows more independent thinkers to be unintentional moderates. The chart is a claim that independence leads to moderation. I deny that. The most independently minded thinkers I know frequently drift off into extremes where most tribes dare not tread. The tribalists are so moderate in comparison that I would turn that christmas tree upside down.


Replies

shw1nlast Wednesday at 8:14 PM

this was based off Paul Graham's piece: https://www.paulgraham.com/mod.html

where individual views may hit extremes, but the average of those views will be in the middle for independent thinkers

his essay explains it better, though I do agree there should be some dots on either end and up high

lanfeust6yesterday at 1:05 PM

Extreme views seem to scale most with education. Those highly decoupled from either tribe can be educated as well, but does seem more common with those less politically engaged. I am optimistic about the resurgence of an "abundance" agenda pushed by center-left Liberals.

> The most independently minded thinkers I know frequently drift off into extremes where most tribes dare not tread.

They've found another tribe.