logoalt Hacker News

ryzvonusef04/03/20257 repliesview on HN

I'm from Pakistan, and the solution to 'it's difficult for people to get ID' was so simple even 3rd world poor illiterate country could do it: just go to them instead.

Our ID department has buses with computers and cameras/fingerprint machines on them, they go to remote villages and stuff and take everyone's bio data, then return a few weeks later and give everyone their cards.

There is literally NO valid excuse for NOT implementing voter ID.

NONE.

If we can do it, the richest country in the world can do it.

Such a pathetic hill for American Democratic party to die on.


Replies

naijaboiler04/03/2025

That’s a government that’s interested and motivated in getting people an ID.

Now imagine the opposite. A government that’s not interested but rather is motivated in denying some people an ID. Why it increases that’s party likelihood of staying in power.

amanaplanacanal04/03/2025

The US doesn't have a national id card, and the people who want to force ID for voting are the strongest block against having one, for religious reasons. What you suggest is impossible in the US.

theGeatZhopa04/03/2025

I think it's on purpose to rather limit the voters than empower them.

show 1 reply
ncallaway04/03/2025

The problem is that we don't have those same systems for getting an ID.

There's no "government comes to you" to give you an ID. And, many Democrats would love to make it easier to get an ID, but the Republicans often deliberately make it harder to get an ID.

They shut down offices and reduce hours of locations, so people have to travel farther and take more time off work. They increase the bureaucratic requirements and hurdles, so people are more likely to need to take multiple trips.

I personally wouldn't have a problem with making a voter ID a requirement to vote, if we could also agree to make it as easy as you describe to get an ID. The problem is the GOP wants to require getting a voter ID and simultaneously make it harder to get an ID.

show 1 reply
pasc187804/03/2025

The problem in the US is they are not doing this if anything they are reducing the number of places you can get an ID.

show 1 reply
gambiting04/03/2025

I think the problem there is that in Pakistan where they do this they can reasonably assume that everyone in that remote village is a Pakistani citizen - they probably don't need to see your birth certificate to get you an ID, right? In US they want to see proof that you are a citizen and you are who you say you are, which is what (some) people have an issue with, even if you sent buses with all equipment on them to random american towns people just might not have the right documentation on them to pass the checks.

But yes, I agree, it is a pathetic problem for a 1st world country to have - just sort it out.

show 1 reply