logoalt Hacker News

jimnotgymyesterday at 7:44 AM2 repliesview on HN

I'm interested in this as a faster intervention than QE. $10 given to a low income family will likely be spent that week. $10 of QE will just sit on somebodies balance sheet.

Understanding BI as a tool of monetary policy seems to remove the ideologically charged view we see when it is considered as part of the welfare state


Replies

creeryesterday at 9:31 PM

> I'm interested in this as a faster intervention than QE.

But BI / UBI's usual argument is that because it would be long term and reliable, it would allow the recipients to make long term choices. Such as taking on an occupation they like rather than one that pays better.

If you make this an intervention medium, you loose this predictability.

The intervention style you discuss has been used during the Covid crisis: just mail checks to people based on last known year income. That's always available. It's not a question of basic income.

dinfinityyesterday at 4:34 PM

Another angle: We tell people to "vote with their wallet" to let the better producers rise to the top. That works a lot better if more people actually have something in their wallet to vote with.