logoalt Hacker News

csmpltn04/03/20256 repliesview on HN

VAT is effectively a tariff though, because it disincentivizes import/trade with the US (and other foreign countries). Since the US has no VAT, it's leading to unfair competition.


Replies

davejohnclark04/03/2025

Good write up here https://www.economicforces.xyz/p/stop-saying-a-value-added-t... about how VAT doesn't alter the levelness of the playing field re imports and exports

show 1 reply
grodriguez10004/03/2025

No, VAT is not a tariff. It applies to all goods sold, not only imported ones.

arlort04/03/2025

VAT applies equally to domestic and foreign companies. It's a tax.

Tariffs and barriers to trade are measures meant to incentivize production in the country imposing them. That's what free trade is meant to get rid of, that's why Trump is so keen on tariffs and likes them

If a company moved a production line to within the EU from outside because of VAT they'd still have to pay the same exact amount of VAT as they did before. It's just not an incentive in that sense

olejorgenb04/03/2025

Repeating this does not lead to understanding. Give a concrete example of how the rules applies which show your point...

sam_lowry_04/03/2025

US has sales taxes.

If anything, VAT incentivizes sustainable economy by making production more expensive than reuse.

anigbrowl04/03/2025

Bullshit. VAT is levied on domestic and imported goods, from the consumer's point of view there is absolutely no difference.