logoalt Hacker News

djrj477dhsnv04/23/20254 repliesview on HN

As long as populations are managed to avoid loss of biodiversity, I think it's hard to argue hunting is evil.

Animals hunting other animals is a natural part of life.


Replies

andrewflnr04/23/2025

The only responsible way to "manage" whale populations is to let them repopulate for at least a hundred years, probably more. IIRC their populations are still way below pre-whaling levels, with some weird knock-on effects.

show 1 reply
rl304/23/2025

>... I think it's hard to argue hunting is evil.

Very few if any clean kills, infliction of immense suffering on creatures that have a cognitive capacity rivaling that of humans prior to robbing them of life, clear lack of necessity in the first place.

I dunno, seems kind of evil to me. This makes a good argument that the cruelty involved is undue:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=D8e1kb4D4nY

lostlogin04/23/2025

> Animals hunting other animals is a natural part of life.

Would you extend this to humans hunting humans?

show 1 reply
DonHopkins04/23/2025

By your own argument, there's certainly enough biodiverse human population to justify hunting. Hunting and eating humans has always been a natural part of life.

If God didn't mean for people to hunt and eat other people, they wouldn't be made of meat.

show 1 reply