logoalt Hacker News

skeptruneyesterday at 5:09 AM1 replyview on HN

Low count suggests that the project has an intentionally built core and doesn't undergo churn or feature creep. It's also a good sign that commits per week have decreased substantially over time.

Contributions being mostly from a single developer lends further credence to that idea, because it implies everything is fueled by one person's relatively opinionated vision and taste.


Replies

smt88yesterday at 6:12 AM

This conclusion is deeply divorced from reality.

A single(-ish) author is the strongest smell for a library. I've been burned countless times by a project's "BDFL" moving on to something else. Sometimes a new maintainer will take over, but it's rare.

Low commit count also suggests unresponsiveness to issues that are filed, especially for a TypeScript or JavaScript project.

This thread single-handedly convinced me not to start a Solid project.

show 2 replies