logoalt Hacker News

amarcheschi04/23/20251 replyview on HN

Yesterday I had someone here tell me timnit gebru didn't contribute to hard science

She has a PhD in electrical engineering and has worked at Google before researching on Ai with a more philosophical approach


Replies

elefanten04/23/2025

Putting aside the nebulous notion "contribution to hard science"...

She became famous for adopting a strain of strident and problematic activism, using it to attack her colleagues and making claims just as wild as some of the ones she cherry picks to critique.

It's not at all surprising that she ended up an extremely divisive figure. And meanwhile, the state of the art sped far ahead of where she drew her line in the sand.

It's hard to find discussion of her that isn't strongly biased in one direction or another (surely, my own comment included). In my experience (sample size 1), when she gets brought up (or involved), the quality of the discussion usually plummets.

show 1 reply