logoalt Hacker News

Animats04/23/20256 repliesview on HN

The real question is when AIs figure out that they should be talking to each other in something other than English. Something that includes tables, images, spreadsheets, diagrams. Then we're on our way to the AI corporation.

Go rewatch "The Forbin Project" from 1970.[1] Start at 31 minutes and watch to 35 minutes.

[1] https://archive.org/details/colossus-the-forbin-project-1970


Replies

ThrowawayR204/23/2025

Humans are already investigating whether LLMs might work more efficiently if they work directly in latent space representations for the entirety of the calculation: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43744809. It doesn't seem unlikely that two LLMs instances using the same underlying model could communicate directly in latent space representations and, from there, it's not much of a stretch for two LLMs with different underlying models could communicate directly in latent space representations as long as some sort of conceptual mapping between the two models could be computed.

lbhdc04/23/2025

Such an underrated movie. Great watch for anyone interested in classic scifi.

daxfohl04/23/2025

Oh they've been doing that (and pretending not to) for years already. https://hackaday.com/2019/01/03/cheating-ai-caught-hiding-da...

nowittyusername04/23/2025

First time in a while I've watched a movie from the 70's in full. Thanks for the gem...

geraneum04/23/2025

> talking to each other in something other than English

WiFi?

otabdeveloper404/24/2025

They don't have an internal representation that isn't English. The embeddings arithmetic meme is a lie promulgated by disingenuous people.