logoalt Hacker News

burch4504/23/20252 repliesview on HN

Undefined behavior to access the uninitialized memory. A sanitizer would have flagged that.


Replies

jandrese04/23/2025

The compiler has no way of knowing that the memory would be undefined, not unless it somehow can verify the data file. The most I think it can do is flag the program for not checking the return value of scanf, but even that is unlikely to be true since the program probably was checking for end of file which is also in the return value. It was failing to check the number of matched parameters. This is the kind of error that is easy to miss given the semantics of scanf.

show 2 replies
andrewmcwatters04/23/2025

Yeah, the debugging here is great, but the actual cause is super mild.