alt Hacker News> > Seems like many, if not all, AI applications, when taken to the limit, reduce the need of interaction between humans to 0.
> Same thing here. The better interface is a more capable faster horse. But it isn't an automobile.
I'm over here in "diffusion / generative video" corner scratching my head at all the LLM people making weird things that don't quite have use cases.
We're making movies. Already the AI does things that used to cost too much or take too much time. We can make one minute videos of scale, scope, and consistency in just a few hours. We're in pretty much the sweet spot of the application of this tech. This essay doesn't even apply to us. In fact, it feels otherworldly alien to our experience.
Some stuff we've been making with gen AI to show you that I'm not bullshitting:
- https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Tii9uF0nAx4
- https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7x7IZkHiGD8
- https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_FkKf7sECk4
Diffusion world is magical and the AI over here feels like we've been catapulted 100 years into the future. It's literally earth shattering and none of the industry will remain the same. We're going to have mocap and lipsync, where anybody can act as a fantasy warrior, a space alien, Arnold Schwarzenegger. Literally whatever you can dream up. It's as if improv theater became real and super high definition.
But maybe the reason for the stark contrast with LLMs in B2B applications is that we're taking the outputs and integrating them into things we'd be doing ordinarily. The outputs are extremely suitable as a drop-in to what we already do. I hope there's something from what we do that can be learned from the LLM side, but perhaps the problems we have are just so wholly different that the office domain needs entirely reinvented tools.
Naively, I'd imagine an AI powerpoint generator or an AI "design doc with figures" generator would be so much more useful than an email draft tool. And those are incremental adds that save a tremendous amount of time.
But anyway, sorry about the "horseless carriages". It feels like we're on a rocket ship on our end and I don't understand the public "AI fatigue" because every week something new or revolutionary happens. Hope the LLM side gets something soon to mimic what we've got going. I don't see the advancements to the visual arts stopping anytime soon. We're really only just getting started.
You make some very strong claims and presented material. I hope I am not out of line if I give you my sincere opinion. I am not doing this to be mean, to put you down or to be snarky. But the argument you're making warrants this response, in my opinion.
The examples you gave as "magical", "100 years into the future", "literally earth shattering" are very transparently low effort. The writing is pedestrian, the timing is amateurish and the jokes just don't land. The inflating tea cup with magically floating plate and the cardboard teabag are... bad. These are bad man. At best recycled material. I am sorry but as examples of why using automatically generated art they are making the opposite argument from what you think you're making.
I categorically do not want more of this. I want to see crafted content where talent shines through. Not low effort, automatically generated stuff like the videos in these links.