logoalt Hacker News

xorcist04/23/20254 repliesview on HN

That's why it's kept sealed, under pressure. I wouldn't fill a water bottle and let it sit for many months before drinking it ever today. A beer bottle with CO2 atmosphere can sit for a long time.

There may be other reasons to prefer beer where the alcohol is relevant of course, just not for freshness. And freshness could absolutely have been relevant in the choice of drinks to load, together with low cost and acceptance in general.


Replies

oofManBang04/24/2025

Would technology that allows sealing of beer not apply even better to relatively nutrition-less water? Especially boiled water. Anything that can feed off of pottery + water or metal + water or glass + water is gonna take a lot longer to grow than basically any kind of familiar bacteria feeding off beer + any of the above.

> There may be other reasons to prefer beer where the alcohol is relevant of course

I imagine these are largely the same reasons people drink beer today. Spoiler: it generally ain't hydration or avoidance of disease.

show 1 reply
wqaatwt04/24/2025

Sealing liquids user pressure on a large scale wasn’t really feasible back in those days though. They were just generally kept in wooden barrels.

show 1 reply
bohrbohra04/24/2025

What exactly would happen if I kept water in a sealed glass bottle and drank it after a year ?