logoalt Hacker News

aprxi04/24/20252 repliesview on HN

Cant one enjoy both? After all, coding with AI in practice is still coding, just with a far higher intensity.


Replies

ang_cire04/24/2025

It is absolutely possible to enjoy both- I have used LLMs to generate code for ideas about alternate paths to take when I write my code- but prompt generation is not coding, and there are WAY too many people who claim to be coding when they have in fact done nothing of the sort.

> a far higher intensity

I'm not sure what this is supposed to mean. The code that I've gotten is riddled with mistakes and fabrications. If I were to use it directly, it would significantly slow my pace. Likewise, when I use LLMs to offer alternative methods to accomplish something, I have to take the time to sit down and understand what they're proposing, how to actually make it work, and whether that route(s) would be better than my original idea. That is a significant speed reduction.

The only way I can imagine LLMs resulting in "far higher intensity" is if I was just yolo'ing the code into my program, and then doing frantic integration, correction, and bugfix work afterwards.

Sure, that's "higher intensity", but that's just working harder and not smarter.

show 1 reply
bluefirebrand04/24/2025

It is not coding the same way riding a bus is not driving

You may get to the same destination, but it is not the same activity