logoalt Hacker News

os2warpman04/24/20251 replyview on HN

The payload on that flight was a single stuffed toy banana, for scale.

On all test flights with a payload exceeding the mass (~300 grams) of a single stuffed toy banana (for scale), the flight has failed.

Flight 7: 20,000 kg payload (starlink mass simulators) - engines fail after 7m39s

Flight 8: 8,000 kg payload (starlink mass simulators) - engines fail after 8m04s

Flight 9 is not currently planned to carry a payload.

None of this is a technicality. It is technicreality.


Replies

FL33TW00D04/24/2025

Agree there are obviously still issues, but you've just made the case yourself. We are discussing Flight 9 for Starship ~5 years into development. 10 years into the development of SLS we won't even see launch 2.

They just operate in different universes no matter how much you dislike the CEO.

show 1 reply