> Because sometimes, dishonest people do win.
Dishonest people almost always win.
Not any individual one - a particular dishonest person might only win 20% of the time - but in aggregate - the winner is almost always a dishonest person.
Even when a game rewards honesty, dishonest people are willing to be honest if that's truly what gives them the greatest chance of winning, so they still win.
Is this some kind of inverse no true scotsman?
If you win by being honest that’s not dishonest.