logoalt Hacker News

TheOtherHobbesyesterday at 8:45 PM1 replyview on HN

Racism and climate denial are both narratives, and people die because of them every day. (If you're not aware of how many people are already dying because of climate change, it's not because the facts aren't available to the curious and interested.)

Patriarchy is more complex. I dislike the feminist tendency to use it as shorthand for "Everything wrong with the world" - as if the world was naturally a utopia until patriarchs took over.

But there are certainly elements that are immensely destructive.

The point is that narratives define morality and self. If every movie you see features the Good Guy heroically struggling to kill the Bad Guy, that becomes the unconscious default narrative that defines your sense of self and your moral choices.

Which is why Main Character Energy is a real thing - and often not in a good way.

If you are exposed to a much wider range of plots, with more ambiguity, more complex outcomes, much richer and more challenging social relationships, and so on, you're less likely to believe that you can fix any problem with muscles, a gun, and some wisecracks.

I'll admit I don't think Le Guin manages to do this. I think she's very on-the-nose as a moralist - she's almost the anti-Heinlein.

And being a moralist is - ironically - very much a hero's journey trope itself, with the violence sublimated into words instead of weapons.


Replies

jimbokuntoday at 12:00 AM

I think the argument that watching movies with a different narrative structure will solve major geopolitical issues requires more evidence.