logoalt Hacker News

lionkortoday at 12:36 AM4 repliesview on HN

Show the training set, and PROVE that the tasks and answers aren't in there. I don't understand why this is not a default first step for proving that this is creating new knowledge.


Replies

Davidzhengtoday at 12:59 AM

Well that's harder than maybe solving well-known open problems (whose soln's are presumably not in training set lol) but it seems that their examples are not clearly breaking sota, especially on matmul

thatguysaguytoday at 1:39 AM

Are you claiming that for the open problems they give record-breaking solutions for, there were just answers on the web waiting to be found?

show 1 reply
thw09j9mtoday at 3:09 AM

It's Google. Assume the training set contains, as a subset, the entirety of all public digitized information. How would you like to them to share it?

show 2 replies
tananaevtoday at 12:41 AM

How can you actually verify it, even if they provide something?

show 1 reply