logoalt Hacker News

soraminazuki05/15/20251 replyview on HN

I'm speaking from direct experience over the past few years, from my home, work, and outside with a phone. Do you actually browse GitHub anonymously, or are you reflexively shifting blame?

If you need more proof, this is last year:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39322838

And this is another year before that:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36254129

Oh look, there's even visual proof in the discussion:

https://imgur.com/a/github-search-gated-behind-login-BT6uRIe


Replies

naikrovek05/15/2025

Yes I actually browse GitHub anonymously. Not always but I do it every day. Never once had a problem.

In another browser I log in because I do work with code in GitHub frequently. I comment on issues and PRs and all the normal stuff.

I regularly drive two browsers, yes. I alternate between them multiple times per minute, often. In one, I am not logged in. In the other, I am logged in.

Not once have I hit any anonymous rate limit.

I respect one’s desire to use something without logging in, that’s fine. But what you do when you use up the free tier of a service is one of the following: A) you pay for the next tier, B) you (in this case) log in so that your usage is no longer considered “anonymous”, or C) you wait for the next usage measurement period to begin so that you can resume.

It’s their service and they can decide how they want to provide it, in the exact same way that you can decide how to provide any services that you might provide.

If it is your privacy that you are considering by not having an account, fine. By making that choice you are limiting yourself to whatever the services you use decide to give you, and you are entitled to nothing.

“I could do more in the past!” So what? They decided to let you do more in the past, and now they’ve decided to let you do less. They don’t owe you free services; you choose to use the free service and by doing so you’ve chosen to be bound by any usage caps that they decide to apply to you.

Nobody owes you free services AT ALL, but you’re getting them anyway. Instead of feeling entitled to more than you’re getting, maybe be thankful for what you have.

show 1 reply