logoalt Hacker News

New study casts doubt on the likelihood of Milky Way collision with Andromeda

49 pointsby layer8last Tuesday at 10:45 PM58 commentsview on HN

Comments

anshumankmrlast Wednesday at 5:11 AM

>If the Milky Way and Andromeda are to collide and merge, the researchers found that it would most likely happen in 7 to 8 billion years’ time, significantly later than previously predicted.

Aah damn well let me check my calendar for what I'll being doing in 7 billion years instead of 4...

didgetmasterlast Wednesday at 3:14 AM

When simulating an actual merger with the two galaxies; any estimates on the number of stars that might collide?

400+ billion stars per galaxy might make each one seem 'dense' but the distance between stars is enormous.

I have heard that it might be possible for one galaxy to pass through another without any stars colliding with each other. I don't have any idea if that is actually true.

show 5 replies
lIl-IIIllast Wednesday at 8:02 AM

The article:

>Such a collision would be devastating for both galaxies which would be destroyed, leaving behind a spheroidal pile of stars known as an elliptical galaxy.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Andromeda%E2%80%93Milky_Way_...:

>The stars involved are sufficiently spaced that it is improbable that any of them will individually collide,[6] though some stars will be ejected.

Originally I thought thought those statements were contradictory, but I guess the first statement says the galaxies will be destroyed, and says nothing of the stars.

show 2 replies
spenczar5last Wednesday at 2:32 AM

I could have told you in advance it would have been a Finn! Something in Helsinki has been going on for a while in astronomy. They're so much more willing to challenge the norm, and unusually capable with Bayesian statistics and big computation. It's really remarkable.

gnabgiblast Wednesday at 1:49 AM

Related:

Milky Way may escape fated collision with Andromeda galaxy (9 points, 10 months ago) https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41240641

Milky Way and Andromeda galaxies are already merging (2020) (138 points, 2022, 74 comments) https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30494523

Our Dazzling Night Sky When the Milky Way Collides with Andromeda in 4B Years (182 points, 2019, 120 comments) https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21327269

lisperlast Wednesday at 2:57 AM

Damn, I was really looking forward to seeing Andromeda up close. Oh well.

show 1 reply
braiamplast Wednesday at 1:15 AM

It only cast doubts in the time frame. Everything in our local region will merge eventually.

show 4 replies
svachaleklast Wednesday at 1:59 PM

> Such a collision would be devastating for both galaxies which would be destroyed, leaving behind a spheroidal pile of stars known as an elliptical galaxy.

Where the heck did this sentence come from, especially on a university website?! Is it AI slop or did a human actually write this?

block_daggerlast Wednesday at 4:54 AM

Collide? No; merge.

show 1 reply