alt Hacker NewsErrors are just values, same as other values, it's in no way "exceptional" for a caller to get an error back from a call to some other code. If a function can fail it needs to return an error, if a function call fails the caller needs to deal with that error, not difficult stuff here. "Happy path" is no more or less important than "sad path" and both should be equally represented in the source code as written.
That's doctrine. Saying it doesn't make it useful.
A program serves a business need: so it's well recognized that there's a distinction between business logic, and then implementation details.
So there's obviously no such thing as "just an error" from that alone: because "a thing failed because we ran out of disk space" is very different to "X is not valid because pre-1984 dated titles are not covered under post-2005 entitlement law".
All elephants have 4 legs, but not all things with 4 legs are elephants, and a tiger inside the elephant enclosure isn't "just" another animal.