alt Hacker NewsThis is trying to do multiple things (commit info & file diff) in one. Not a good idea. Commit info should live in the repo metadata (no matter which form this takes), and diff should be its own thing.
This is trying to do multiple things (commit info & file diff) in one. Not a good idea. Commit info should live in the repo metadata (no matter which form this takes), and diff should be its own thing.
The repository metadata absolutely should own the commit information.
Diff files are there to represent a delta state of the repository, a difference between a range of changes. Those may be one or more commits, or one more changes across individual files (not all SCMs manage state in terms of atomic commits). File changes, file attribute changes, SCM-specific metadata changes, and commit history information.
That delta state should be able to be applied to another tree in order to get the same end result. This is what diff files are ultimately there for.
Git diffs do this today, and they do it well (but they're pretty Git-specific). Many SCMs (and there are a lot of them) don't include a format on that level, or a format at all. Hence DiffX.