logoalt Hacker News

donatjlast Wednesday at 2:35 PM1 replyview on HN

These all seem like things that are more work to instruct and AI to do then to just do yourself


Replies

cjlast Wednesday at 2:43 PM

Where a lot of these tools fail is "first instruction accuracy". Put another way, what percent of requests are fulfilled accurately without needing to clarify your intention to the AI.

For voice assistants to really work, they need to nail the request on the first attempt in 95%+ of cases.

When the first time success rate for a request drops too low, it indeed becomes way easier to just do it yourself rather than asking the voice assistant for help.

The fact that we haven't solved this problem for basic things like turning on or off a TV doesn't give me much confidence in the future of voice assistants. I find myself frustratingly repeating commands to Siri way too often.