logoalt Hacker News

malfist06/16/20254 repliesview on HN

Fiber transmits light, not rf. To get power out of fiber optics you have to have a photovoltaic cell on the other side and there's a limit for how much those can produce with such a collaminated light source.

Using fiber optics for power is like trying to make a solar panel generate electricity from a laser beam.


Replies

demod606/16/2025

"trying to make a solar panel generate electricity from a laser beam" is literally what the article is about.

TeMPOraL06/16/2025

> Using fiber optics for power is like trying to make a solar panel generate electricity from a laser beam.

Isn't that exactly what power beaming is, except typically with frequency range in microwaves instead of visible light?

show 1 reply
contrarian123406/16/2025

just have a tiny steam turbine equivalent...? (some thermoelectric generator) You don't really need to be efficient. You have fans to blow air and dissipate heat on the other end after all

show 1 reply
ben_w06/16/2025

I have no idea why this might be limited by the light source being collimated?

I mean, you can get electricity from PV illuminated by a laser, and everything I've heard so far says it's easier than with sunlight because you can match the frequency of the laser to the band gap of the PV.

show 1 reply