logoalt Hacker News

kgwgk06/16/20252 repliesview on HN

> Entropy isn't a function of imperfect knowledge. It's a function of the possible states of a system and their probability distributions.

There are no probability distributions over possible states when there is perfect knowledge of the state.

> Quantum mechanics

Entropy is also zero for a pure quantum state. You won’t have entropy without imperfect knowledge.


Replies

whereismyacc06/16/2025

> There are no probability distributions over possible states when there is perfect knowledge of the state.

I know very little about physics but I thought that the leading interpretations of quantum physics say that the probability distribution is all we can know about a system. The entropy is not due to due to a lack of information about the quantum state, but because the outcomes are inherently stochastic?

show 1 reply
mr_mitm06/16/2025

Just look at the definition of entropy. Knowledge about a system never enters the equation.

S := -k_B sum p_i ln (p_i)

show 2 replies