logoalt Hacker News

kgwxd06/16/20256 repliesview on HN

No cut is reasonable.


Replies

esteth06/16/2025

Presumably the prison is providing the "office" where the person works from, the Internet connection, etc.

show 1 reply
jjmarr06/16/2025

They need money to pay for oversight. Any time prisoners talk to someone on the outside, it's a potential conduit for contraband or organized crime.

show 1 reply
bryanrasmussen06/16/2025

"No cut" is reasonable, but also "Some cut" is reasonable. However while arguing that "no cut" should be mandatory is reasonable, given that "no cut" would itself be reasonable, it is probably not pragmatic. Therefore in order to best support this kind of thing one should determine exactly how much "some cut" should be.

show 1 reply
conductr06/16/2025

I disagree. The cut should support the program itself and then further offset taxpayer expenses related to housing, feeding, and caring for the prisoner. I could even see a case for taking it as a way of ensuring it was saved and returned at release.

show 1 reply
mp0506/16/2025

Don't you suppose that it's "fair" to request compensation for the room and board if the person is making a "fair" wage?

show 3 replies
hashstring06/16/2025

Why would it not be reasonable?

show 1 reply