logoalt Hacker News

lenerdenator06/16/20251 replyview on HN

I only got as far as undergraduate research assistant in the academia racket, so maybe I'm not "with it" in the way serious researchers are, but is this to suggest that this wasn't being done, by default, on everything already?


Replies

fc417fc80206/16/2025

Any reputable journal had a reasonably robust peer review process (exact details vary of course) but historically it was strictly confidential. Only over the past perhaps 2 decades has a process where reviews are made public begun to gain mainstream support.