alt Hacker NewsI think some context I probably don't share with the rest of this thread is that the average quality of a Hacker One submission is incredibly low. Like however bad you think the median bounty submission is, it's worse; think "people threatening to take you to court for not paying them for their report that they can 'XSS' you with the Chrome developer console".
Replies
We‘ll get this low quality submissions with AI too.
The problem is that the people who know how to use AI properly will slower and more careful in their submissions.
Many others won’t, so we‘ll get lots of noise hiding the real issues. AI makes it easy to produce many bad results in short time.
I can’t speak to the average quality of submissions, as I’ve only made one to HackerOne myself iirc. I don’t even consider myself good at coding or aware of how to file a bug report or bounty submission. I reported that on iOS Coinbase app, that if you were on a VPN, the Coinbase app PIN simply didn’t exist anymore, and did not appear in the settings as enabled either. I included a full video of this occurring and it seemed reproducible. The Coinbase person said that this was not an issue because you would already need access to the physical device and know the iOS passcode; relevant to this is that at the time (2021) and maybe now, the Coinbase iOS app didn’t hook the iOS passcode for access control, like Signal or other apps do, but instead has its own app passcode. The fact that this was circumventable by adding and connecting to any VPN on the same iOS device seemed like a bug in the implementation, even if it is the code working as written. The issue was closed and I lost 5 HackerRank I think the points are called. It felt very hostile to my efforts that I lost points, since I don’t think that was justified. Perhaps that is just how the platform works for denied bug reports on HackerOne, but I have no way of knowing that, as the Coinbase report is the only time I used the platform.
My favorite one I've seen is "open redirect when you change the domain name in the browser address bar". This was submitted twice several years apart by two different people.