alt Hacker NewsI'm not saying you're wrong but this is also much the same argument as "why do I pay more tax when I am not using public health" or other community wide benefits. Philosophically you either believe in a price which benefits the community at large, or you want the lowest price outcome for yourself and others to be exposed to their costs.
Replies
>Philosophically you either believe in a price which benefits the community at large, or you want the lowest price outcome for yourself and others to be exposed to their costs.
How does the community benefit when there's only one price for airfare, and there isn't any mechanism for the poor to save a buck? I rarely rebook tickets, probably because I rarely fly for work, so I can book tickets months in advance. I suspect it's the same for most vacationers, so they're benefiting from this policy, likely at the expense of people who need to cancel last minute (corporate flyers?). The same goes for meals. Is it really that hard to pack a lunch that we need to mandate free lunches for everyone?
I think then you have to provide a strong argument for why a particular product/service should be considered under the "community-wide benefit" umbrella.
Public health is very clearly to me a collective good: I benefit from others being healthy in so many ways. Similar things can be said about funding schools; I don't have children, but I will benefit from the next generation of adults being well-educated. Welfare and supportive housing reduces crime and general dirtiness and decay where I live, so I'm happy that my taxes go toward that (I want more going toward that, honestly). I don't need to make arguments involving empathy to prove these things make sense, which is good when there are so many people not motivated by empathy.
But I'm not sure affordable flights is a public good. Certainly I want air travel to be accessible to more people; it shouldn't be the kind of thing only well-off people can do. (When I was a kid in the 80s/90s, we didn't have the money to fly, which limited our vacation choices.) But I'm not convinced that regulation should aim to "redistribute" cost so that people like myself should pay more for flights so others can pay less; that doesn't feel like it benefits me or the "public", really.
In general, though, I think the market is actually working for once. Airlines have unbundled a lot of things, and then there's basic economy as well. Even with airline consolidation, (inflation-adjusted) fares are pretty low, and if you want a basic economy fare, or even a regular economy fare (but without checked baggage or refunds or changes), you can get a pretty good price.