logoalt Hacker News

vmayoraltoday at 6:05 AM1 replyview on HN

It’s humans who:

- Design the system and prompts

- Build and integrate the attack tools

- Guide the decision logic and analysis

This isn’t just semantics — overstating AI capabilities can confuse the public and mislead buyers, especially in high-stakes security contexts.

I say this as someone actively working in this space. I participated in the development of PentestGPT, which helped kickstart this wave of research and investment, and more recently, I’ve been working on Cybersecurity AI (CAI) — the leading open-source project for building autonomous agents for security:

- CAI GitHub: https://github.com/aliasrobotics/cai

- Tech report: https://arxiv.org/pdf/2504.06017

I’m all for pushing boundaries, but let’s keep the messaging grounded in reality. The future of AI in security is exciting — and we’re just getting started.


Replies

vascotoday at 6:51 AM

> It's humans

Who would it be, gremlins? Those humans weren't at the top of the leaderboard before they had the AI, so clearly it helps.