They have a concept of "rando" as you can see above. They don't usually say that out aloud.

Basically if you are new, the reviewer thinks "oh, a rando" and in his mind he has already downgraded the severity a bit.

It's unfortunately a kind of cartel at this point. Not full fledged and out but a low key cartel. They have a circle of friends whose csrf would also get better valuation. It's a sorry state.