logoalt Hacker News

jillesvangurptoday at 8:18 AM4 repliesview on HN

Old PNGs will work just fine. And forward compatibility is much less important.

The main use case for PNG is web browsers and all of them seem to be on board. Using old web browsers is a bad idea. You do get these relics showing up using some old version of internet explorer. But some images not rendering is the least of their problems. The main challenge is actually going to be updating graphics tools to export the new files. And teaching people that sRGB maybe isn't good enough any more. That's going to be hard since most people have no clue about color spaces.

Anyway, that gives everybody plenty of time to upgrade. By the time this stuff is widely used, it will be widely supported. So, you kind of get forward compatibility that way. Your browser already supports the new format. Your image editor probably doesn't.


Replies

hnlmorgtoday at 9:00 AM

Browsers aren't the only software that work with PNGs. Far from it in fact.

whywhywhywhytoday at 2:25 PM

> The main use case for PNG is web browsers

It's not, most images you encounter on the web need better compression.

The main PNG use case is to store lossless images locally as master copies that are then compressed or in workflows where you intend to edit and change them where compressed formats would degrade the more they were edited.

AlienRobottoday at 11:36 AM

>The main use case for PNG is web browsers

This is news to me. I'm pretty sure the main use case for PNG is lossless transparent graphics.

show 1 reply