logoalt Hacker News

voxleoneyesterday at 7:08 PM2 repliesview on HN

> Language and vision are just the beginning — the parts we were able to digitize first - not necessarily the most central to intelligence.

I probably made a mistake when i asserted that -- should have thought it over. Vision is evolutionarily older and more “primitive”, while language is uniquely human [or maybe, more broadly, primate, cetacean, cephalopod, avian...] symbolic, and abstract — arguably a different order of cognition altogether. But i maintain that each and every sense is important as far as human cognition -- and its replication -- is concerned.


Replies

dinfinitytoday at 5:14 AM

Vision is interesting in that it leverages the maximum speed with which it is easily possible to gather information about our surroundings in this universe. I believe that is what makes it special and very valuable. I also believe this aspect makes it a strong attractor for convergent evolution.

Language allows encoding and compression of information about the world, which is of course incredibly powerful and increases communication bandwidth enormously (as well as tons of other stuff).

I'd say that for high level cognitive processes, hearing and speaking were an important stepping stone because for some reason evolving organs that can generate relatively high bandwidth signals in audio seems to be easier than evolving something that does that for visuals (very few Teletubby screens on tummies in the natural world).

Interesting games to think about in this sense: Pictionary/drawing games and charades.

show 1 reply
wizzwizz4yesterday at 7:56 PM

People who lack one of those senses, or even two of them, tend to do just fine.

show 1 reply