logoalt Hacker News

darkwaterlast Monday at 8:01 PM3 repliesview on HN

Why the focus on S3 for a self-hosted app? Anyway kudos for the effort, I'm not experiencing performance issues in my locally self-hosted Immich installation but more performant software is always welcome.


Replies

toomuchtodolast Monday at 11:53 PM

S3 compatible means one can point it at any storage that talks S3, which is a lot more flexible than POSIX or NFS.

jasonjayrlast Monday at 10:24 PM

I have and love my self-hosted immich install. If self-hosted could also use S3 storage, that allows me to use Garage (https://git.deuxfleurs.fr/Deuxfleurs/garage) , which also lets me play games with growable/redundant storage on a pile of second-hand hard drives. IIRC it can only use a mounted block device at the moment, (unless there is a nfs-exposed s3 translator ....)

A lot of existing tooling supports the s3 protocol, so it would simplify the storage picture (no pun intended).

rkagererlast Monday at 8:33 PM

I'm wondering the same thing. He had me until he said "S3".

show 1 reply