logoalt Hacker News

ndriscolllast Tuesday at 2:53 PM1 replyview on HN

Yes that's the point. You don't need those things. The idea that a news article or blog post or e-commerce page could "crash" is ridiculous, and the law shouldn't humor that excuse. There's been standard ways to declaratively define such pages since before scripting frameworks gained popularity. Use those standard ways. If you're really building an app and need to performance test, buy some hardware in your target range. Privacy aware users block things like Sentry.


Replies

dcowlast Tuesday at 4:20 PM

You don’t need a shopping cart either. Just make the user write down the skus from your online catalog and send you a purchase order. Products exist on spectrum and the ones that win are typically easier and more convenient to use. If your business is developing the best product it can, it absolutely needs the ability to be convenient and useful.

Adding a language select option on a multinational site seems pretty table stakes in my experience. Plenty often the user does not wish to use the same language as their system/browser. Switching your system’s default language just for one site is a huge hassle.

Re crash reporting: I’m talking about tools like Sentry. I have never once worked on a product of any scale that didn’t need to collect diagnostic reports from the field in order to address code level errors that happen as users are using the product. In house or 3rd party it doesn't matter, and client state has always been involved. A product that doesn’t function is broken. It needs to be fixed.

There is no privacy concession in any of these cases. The EPD simply over-regulates cookies.

I mean maybe we should just reimplement all this crap using indexdb. That’s not a cookie, legally.

The EPD fights symptoms not causes and the internet is worse for it.

show 4 replies